The Awful Waffle Walker from Quest for Glory 3. Sounds like syrupy deliciousness. Just a bit rapey, though.
Quite terrifying, especially with that game's combat controls. But sometimes the fans can come up with food monsters that are more grand in scale. Like the pizza elemental.
The Beast Flesh from Pandora's Tower seems scrumptious.
The rice balls in Harvest Moon. I always thought they were donuts, because nothing ever explained what they were. Didn't help that when Pokemon had them they called them 'jelly-filled donuts' (among other things)
the Pizza from TMNT, I mean street pizza that heals you? Its gotta be good right?
What I really find weird is that I've always wondered what an Antwerp would taste like. They look so cute and so tasty. I always imagined them tasting like blue raspberry jello or like a gummi bear. Though I think chewing them would be damn risky.
They look like eggplants, I assumed they'd taster like some kind of peculiar bell pepper.