Let's play Werewolf on the forums!

[Muckfoot]

Figured Biz would choose me, my own fault for not keeping my mouth shut I guess.

The funny thing was we debated whether to kill Dex or Used, judging from the deaths it wouldn't have mattered har har.

Also the rules indicate that a team must wipeout the other in order to win, the wolves don't win by having an equal number to the villagers... This is something I hadn't realised until now.

[Muckfoot]

Us wolfs should have been aiming to get the sheriff role for ourselves, it would have been the only way to win.

Lame. Should of read the rules.

[usedtabe]

Damn, I chose wrong. Was so close to picking FTR because he had been playing so "helpful" but went with Artful instead.

*Edit* Wolves have to wipe out the team to win, meaning getting the Sheriff role? Fucking nice little detail that probably slipped everybody's notice. Tip my hat to Byronic if so.

[Muckfoot]

Damn, I chose wrong. Was so close to picking FTR because he had been playing so "helpful" but went with Artful instead.

I think artful was Cupid.

[ZombiePlatypus]

I think artful was Cupid.

That's definitely the vibe I got from his posts.


Also, Jdawg was totally a wolf. Don't believe the flavor text for one moment.

[FromTheRiver]

Hmm. IF the sheriff vote still counts for 2 votes when there is only one villager then their are only two conditions thw wolves can win under - one of the wolves is the sheriff OR there are two wolves remaining with one sheriff villager. Tough but not impossible I guess! We'll just have to see what happens here =o]

[Dexter345]

Voting never had anything to do with it, the game just ends when the wolves get the villagers down to their level.

It shouldn't matter that he has two votes, as he's the only villager left. Thematically he would vote, he would agree, and the werewolf would eat his ass when he tries to hang it by himself.

Of course that's on Byron I guess.

Wrong. The "Werewolves win when they achieve parity" rule is only there because in the standard game, there is no way to win from that point on. In this situation, Bizarro can outvote FromTheRiver, meaning the Villagers will win. Or at least, that's how I'd rule it if I were running it.

[Muckfoot]

The worst thing is it appears that none of us wolves seemed aware of the different rules.

Hindsight is an awful, awful thing.

[Byronic Man]

Votes to lynch

1. Zombie Platypus
2. Usedtabe
3. Artful-dodgeR
4. Muckfoot
5. Mighty Hatman
6. ClownBaby
7. Bizarro [Sheriff] - FTR
8. Dexter
9. FromTheRiver - Bizarro
10. Jdawg1989
11. Bleep

The two remaining townsfolk eyed each other up. They both knew something was amiss. Something... amiss. Without warning, FromTheRiver let out what began as a low demonic laugh but slowly transformed into a long piercing howl. As it trailed off, the wolf lowered his head and grinned an unsettlingly toothy grin at the sole remaining villager. Bizarro shuddered, reached into his pocket and in one swift movement raised his deputy whistle to his lips and blew. Out of nowhere twenty bobbies sprang onto the scene and apprehended FromTheRiver, his struggles futile in the face of justice. One of the bobbies commended Bizarro on nabbing the villain, to which he gave a rather witty reply, and everyone present laughed heartily.

Then FTR was lynched because of game mechanics.

FTR is dead. He was a wolf.


A winner is Villagers.


1. Zombie Platypus - villager
2. Usedtabe - vigilante [Lover]
3. Artful-dodgeR - cupid
4. Muckfoot - wolf
5. Mighty Hatman - villager
6. ClownBaby - wolf
7. Bizarro - witch
8. Dexter - villager
9. FromTheRiver - thief/wolf
10. Jdawg1989 - villager
11. Bleep - seer

[Bizarro]

That would explain things.

The only thing I'm still wondering about is whether the Little Girl was in play and how that worked out. Was it Hatman? If so I'm sorry for letting you die but I was just playing the odds, I wanted to save my potion for myself or another important confirmed role. This is also the reason I let you die ZP, I figured since you were going for Sheriff you probably weren't a special role like the Seer or one of the Lovers.

Ninja'd, no Little Girl then? I feel a bit better about my selfishness now.

[Muckfoot]

I wonder what Bizarro's witty reply was?

[Byronic Man]

I wonder what Bizarro's witty reply was?

I couldn't think of anything but it was really witty.

[usedtabe]

Good game. Like the twist for winning.

[Dexter345]

I was pretty sure Artful-dodgeR was Cupid. He hinted at it a few times "having a secret," and he pointed out that I was probably one of the Lovers, but then, everybody knew that. My question to the Werewolves is this: since I was probably one of the Lovers, why didn't you try to kill me first?

I actually tried to be sort of a loose cannon this time, so that the Werewolves might think it better to keep me alive, since I was a liability to the Villagers. After I wasn't killed two nights in, I was almost convinced that usedtabe was one of the Werewolves, and that was the only reason I hadn't been targeted yet.

[usedtabe]

That's funny because I wondered if you were a wolf for the same reason.

[Artful-dodgeR]

I tried to think of a way it's letting used know I was safe but couldn't think of a way. First time cupid, sorry Dex, had to do it to you.

[Dexter345]

Well, the choices were not ideal, because you chose exactly the two people that Bleep chose to look at first as the Seer. Still, it worked out okay in the end, except for the "Lovers only win if they're alive at the end of the game" clause.

[ZombiePlatypus]

First time cupid, sorry Dex, had to do it to you.

God bless you for doing it.

[ClownBaby]

Used and Dex were very high on the list to be killed early on, but we kept you around to draw suspicion away. Until I was looked at, that worked.

[Mighty Hatman]

That would explain things.

The only thing I'm still wondering about is whether the Little Girl was in play and how that worked out. Was it Hatman? If so I'm sorry for letting you die but I was just playing the odds, I wanted to save my potion for myself or another important confirmed role. This is also the reason I let you die ZP, I figured since you were going for Sheriff you probably weren't a special role like the Seer or one of the Lovers.

Ninja'd, no Little Girl then? I feel a bit better about my selfishness now.

I was vanilla. I hate all of you anyway.