Let's play Werewolf on the forums!

[Dexter345]

Even if the rest of the villagers vote to hang Aerox, the majority already has voted to save him. Aerox lives another day. Or at least until the night, anyway.

I was considering automatically putting in votes to hang from the people who nominate and second for somebody to be executed, but I decided against it in case the person being called to trial makes a particularly good argument. Do you guys agree, or should I add in hang votes automatically for the sake of expedience?

[ClownBaby]

I know I'm not in it, but I think it should just count as a call to vote. This way you can call to vote against somebody, see how they react and THEN cast a vote.

Also I don't know if you addressed this, but I think anybody who votes BEFORE the defense post should be allowed to change theirs. But only them, and only once.

[Dexter345]

I think I'd rather just disallow voting before the defense post. I'm also thinking of changing the rule to at least one defense post, where the person on trial can continue to plead his case, though nobody can change a vote after it has been cast.

[ClownBaby]

Well that's ESSENTIALLY how it is right? I say that works fine. I mean, they shouldn't have to stop responding to questions and shit just cause they're on trial.

[Aaron Mxy Yost]

I think I'd rather just disallow voting before the defense post. I'm also thinking of changing the rule to at least one defense post, where the person on trial can continue to plead his case, though nobody can change a vote after it has been cast.

This sounds like a good plan.

[Bleep]

Tell us again how to make the bad go away.

[Bleep]

Two execution trials in one day! I knew you all had murderous tendencies, just waiting to come out.

Should Aerox be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse -
4. Knives - Save
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox - Save
8. Bleep - save
9. Victor - Save
10. KyleGamgee -
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy - Save

Total: 6 Save, 0 Hang

Should Cadtalfryn be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse -
4. Knives -
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox -
8. Bleep - save
9. Victor -
10. KyleGamgee -
11. Cadtalfryn -
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy -

Total: 1 Save, 0 Hang

SAVE / SAVE

[KyleGamgee]

I admit, I am terrified that Aerox is a werewolf. If he is we are toast. I also think it is way easier to survive a trial if you ARE a werewolf because your fellow werewolves will obviously vote to save. (Yikes!)

Like I said, if we never hang anyone we can't win, so official vote: save Aerox/hang Cadtalfryn

[Dexter345]

Should Aerox be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse -
4. Knives - Save
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox - Save
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor - Save
10. KyleGamgee - Save
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy - Save

Total: 8 Save, 0 Hang
Result: Aerox is not executed

Should Cadtalfryn be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse -
4. Knives -
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox -
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor -
10. KyleGamgee - Hang
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy -

Total: 3 Save, 1 Hang
Result: Undetermined

[Zodiac Eclipse]

Save Aerox, Hang Cadtalfryn


We can't just sit and wait for another attack and he hasn't said much to his own defense.

[Byronic Man]

I admit, I am terrified that Aerox is a werewolf. If he is we are toast. I also think it is way easier to survive a trial if you ARE a werewolf because your fellow werewolves will obviously vote to save. (Yikes!)

That's... actually a very good point. I'm interested to see who voted to save whomever without any given reason, now. At the very least, it's reason for suspicion.

As much as I want things to start clicking into motion, I'd prefer to listen to Cadtalfryn's defense first.

[Shinobi13]

I placed my vote already. Hang Aerox.
Fuck second guessing, I've made my decision and am going to stick by it until either he or I is hanged.

[Dexter345]

Should Aerox be executed?

1. Shinobi13 - Hang
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse - Save
4. Knives - Save
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox - Save
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor - Save
10. KyleGamgee - Save
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy - Save

Total: 9 Save, 1 Hang
Result: Aerox is not executed

Should Cadtalfryn be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse - Hang
4. Knives -
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox -
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor -
10. KyleGamgee - Hang
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy -

Total: 3 Save, 2 Hang
Result: Undetermined

[Byronic Man]

Oh do I have to cast my vote so Aerox's trial will finish? In that case, save Aerox.

[Dexter345]

It wasn't necessary, Byronic Man. I was just keeping it updated so people would have all the information of what happened. You know, so you can formulate opinions.

Should Aerox be executed?

1. Shinobi13 - Hang
2. Byronic Man - Save
3. Zodiac Eclipse - Save
4. Knives - Save
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox - Save
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor - Save
10. KyleGamgee - Save
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy - Save

Total: 10 Save, 1 Hang
Result: Aerox is not executed

Should Cadtalfryn be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse - Hang
4. Knives -
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox -
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor -
10. KyleGamgee - Hang
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy -

Total: 3 Save, 2 Hang
Result: Undetermined

[Cadtalfryn]

I foresee you hanging me being detrimental to our continued survival.

[Aerox]

Hang Cadtalfryn​

[Knives]

I foresee you hanging me being detrimental to our continued survival.

Almost the same words Aerox said, and with your previous statement just being "You don't want to do that" there's not that much of a case in your favor. Hang Cadtalfryn

I'm wary of the quiet ones that just let me and victor go at it, and also cautious with Aerox, I'm sure he learned a lot of deceiving from all those Song of Ice and Fire books.

[Glitchy]

Hang Cadtalfryn~


Unless that 'I foresee you hanging me being detrimental to our continued survival.' bit was secretly you hinting that you're the seer or something, in which case I'm being an idiot and we're screwing ourselves over.

[Dexter345]

Should Aerox be executed?

1. Shinobi13 - Hang
2. Byronic Man - Save
3. Zodiac Eclipse - Save
4. Knives - Save
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox - Save
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor - Save
10. KyleGamgee - Save
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy - Save

Total: 10 Save, 1 Hang
Result: Aerox is not executed

Should Cadtalfryn be executed?

1. Shinobi13 -
2. Byronic Man -
3. Zodiac Eclipse - Hang
4. Knives - Hang
5. Bobthecatlol - no vote (dead)
6. Mr Brlghtslde - no vote (dead)
7. Aerox - Hang
8. Bleep - Save
9. Victor -
10. KyleGamgee - Hang
11. Cadtalfryn - Save
12. Aaron Mxy Yost - Save
13. Glitchy - Hang

Total: 3 Save, 5 Hang
Result: Undetermined

Cadtalfryn's life hangs in the balance! What say you, Shinobi13, Byronic Man, Victor?