Let's play Werewolf on the forums!

[ZombiePlatypus]

I think it's pretty obvious that I'm a good guy. The reactor didn't blow, that was on DJ, Byron and Noob. My part of the operation went smoothly, evidenced by us not being locked up right now. As a matter of fact, I'm seeing the security guard again on Thursday. I think she might be "the one", fingers crossed.

[noobspoon]

Okay, what do y'all think of Me, ZP, Mucky and Analogue?

[ZombiePlatypus]

I'm good with that. While I'm not convinced you're not a bad dude, you're lower on my list of suspects than Byron and DJ. I trust Mucky, for whatever reason, and have no read on Analoge.

So yeah, I'm down.

[Analoge]

I'm all for it. At least I know there'll be one member who's true blue AVALANCHE.

[noobspoon]

Cool, then I propose Me, ZP, Mucky and Anologe.

[Muckfoot]

These games make me realise how paranoid I can be, I can't shake the feeling that the spies want us to trust ZP, Byron's decision to bring him
along with the three from the original mission and then to scapegoat him seems almost too straightforward.

Nonetheless I can't think of anyone else to put into the team... maybe swap ZP for Artful, who's been really quiet?

Also who does Noob think is the spy/spies from the failed mission?

[noobspoon]

I don't really have a read on anyone at the moment, if this were werewolf I would be accusing ZP because that's what I always do but there is no one jumping out bat me now. We will only know with time I suppose.

[Analoge]

I definitely get the vibe that Byronic is trying very hard to make us trust him.

[Dexter345]

Sounds like the failure was at an administrative level since I thought we were supposed to be going to Reactor #8, not #6.

Barrett was never very good with numbers.

[Muckfoot]

Using his fingers he can only count to five.

[djnealb]

I'm fine with noob's proposal. I think I would have liked it more had he used 3 new people with one old, but this works too.

[Byronic Man]

Aha! So we know at least one of us was a Spy. My money's on ZP, if only because the other 3 of us succeeded on the first mission.

noobspoon, I'd recommend using the other 4 players for this mission since you can't tell who amongst us 4 was the Spy (or if any more of us are also spies). Also, if you were to include yourself in this next mission it might fudge the results if the mission fails.

I realised afterwards that this doesn't make too much sense given how we have such a limited number of missions left. Disregard!

Again, not a good idea - if you were a spy why would you put all your buddies into the same mission? I reckon someone out of myself, Flam, Analogue and Artful is also a spy.

Aye my thinking was to root them out but, as you can see above, I've seen the problem with that strategy.

Well, I think ZP's the Spy, but sure we'll have more info sure enough.

[noobspoon]

Dex, i don't need to PM you about my proposal do i?

[Muckfoot]

I'm starting to think you're all spies.

You're all Totally Spies.

[Dexter345]

Dex, i don't need to PM you about my proposal do i?

Yes, you do.

[Artful-dodgeR]

About me being quiet... the majority of these discussions happen around 2am-6am for me, it's only just hit 8am (just got the office) so I can finally read what's going on!

I think I like the 2 + 2 option, hopefully it works.

That said I have my eye on Byron... something just doesn't seem right with him.

[Byronic Man]

I love how everybody is very sceptical about me for whatever reason

[Flamoctapus]

It's only because we love you Byron.

Anyway, I'm unable to get much of a read on anyone, and any suspicions I have are little more than the tropes of this game. I'm open to whatever for right now.

That said, I feel like the first mission should be completely disregarded. Those in that group aren't any more proven than the rest of us, as causing a fail on the first mission would have been suicide.

[ZombiePlatypus]

I don't really have a read on anyone at the moment, if this were werewolf I would be accusing ZP because that's what I always do but there is no one jumping out bat me now.

Shit, I'm never a bad dude. Even when I'm a bad dude I'm not a bad dude.

Well, I think ZP's the Spy, but sure we'll have more info sure enough.

D'okay.

[Byronic Man]

That said, I feel like the first mission should be completely disregarded. Those in that group aren't any more proven than the rest of us, as causing a fail on the first mission would have been suicide.

How so? all it would have shown was that one (or more) of three players was a Spy. Not that different than one in four players being a spy, no?